Paper Crafts Scrapbooking Guide: Stickers, Vintage Papers, and Color Cardstock Compared

A shopper-friendly comparison of four paper crafts scrapbooking picks, from vintage sticker packs to themed paper kits and bulk color cardstock.

Last updated Aug 17, 2026

Choosing supplies for paper crafts scrapbooking is really a choice between decoration, background material, and project structure. Stickers can finish a page quickly, vintage papers can create layered journal spreads, and cardstock can become the base for cards, die cuts, banners, and album pages. The right pick depends less on which set has the most pieces and more on whether you need adhesive accents, themed paper layers, or a broad range of solid colors.

Quick take

Best for low-cost vintage accents: 300 Pcs Vintage Stickers, Junk Journal Supplies, Cute Stickers for Journaling keeps the focus on decorative sticker sheets with nature-inspired designs.
Best for colorful project bases: Colored Cardstock 50 Colors Bulk 150 Sheets,12" x 12" Cardstock Paper, 180 GS is the strongest fit when you want many solid color choices for cards, cutting, folding, and paper craft builds.
Best for vintage paper layering: 200 Sheets of Vintage Scrapbook Paper, Journaling 6 Theme suits journals, collages, decoupage, and scrapbook pages that need coordinated paper textures.
Best mixed vintage kit: 517 Pcs Vintage Scrapbook Paper,Scrapbook Supplies Stickers,Journaling Supplies combines scrapbook paper and pressed flower sticker elements in one vintage-themed bundle.

Listed price comparison

The listed prices span $8.65 to $33.14, with the lowest priced item sitting about 74% below the highest priced item. The gap is mostly about format: decorative sticker and paper kits sit lower, while the bulk cardstock pack is the highest listed price.

Product	Listed price	Price bar
300 Pcs Vintage Stickers, Junk Journal Supplies, Cute Stickers for Journaling	USD 8.65
517 Pcs Vintage Scrapbook Paper,Scrapbook Supplies Stickers,Journaling Supplies	USD 10.31
200 Sheets of Vintage Scrapbook Paper, Journaling 6 Theme	USD 21.09
Colored Cardstock 50 Colors Bulk 150 Sheets,12" x 12" Cardstock Paper, 180 GS	USD 33.14

Decision matrix

If your project needs...	Start with...	Why it fits
Fast decoration for journal pages, envelopes, postcards, or gift accents	300 Pcs Vintage Stickers	The set centers on peelable vintage sticker designs, including nature-inspired motifs such as butterflies, ferns, mushrooms, flowers, and plants.
Solid colored material for cutting, folding, punching, or card making	Colored Cardstock 50 Colors Bulk 150 Sheets	It is a paper cardstock pack with a broad color assortment and 180 GSM weight named in the title and description.
Coordinated vintage backgrounds and collage layers	200 Sheets of Vintage Scrapbook Paper	The six-theme paper set includes styles such as flowers, nature, portraits, handwritten script, newspaper advertisements, music sheets, maps, and celestial designs.
A vintage assortment that mixes papers and sticker accents	517 Pcs Vintage Scrapbook Paper	The kit includes multiple design themes plus pressed flower sticker elements, making it useful when you want both layering pieces and accents.

How to choose for paper crafts scrapbooking

Start with the role the supply needs to play. If you already have blank pages, cardstock, or journal inserts, a sticker pack may be enough to add character without adding much bulk. If your pages need backgrounds, torn edges, or collage pieces, a paper set is more useful than stickers alone. If you are building cards, tags, banners, or die-cut shapes from scratch, cardstock is the more practical starting point.

Theme matters too. Three of these choices lean heavily vintage, which works well for junk journals, travel-style pages, botanical layouts, letters, and layered ephemera looks. The cardstock pack goes in a different direction: it is about color range rather than printed vintage imagery. That makes it more flexible for seasonal projects, greeting cards, party decorations, and projects where you want to choose the image or lettering separately.

Piece count is worth reading alongside format. A large number of small paper pieces or stickers can be great for variety, but it does not replace a larger sheet of cardstock when a project needs structure. Likewise, a blank cardstock pack will not provide instant motifs the way flower, postcard, music, map, or nature-themed scrapbook pieces can.

Concise product notes

300 Pcs Vintage Stickers, Junk Journal Supplies, Cute Stickers for Journaling

This is the simplest pick if your main goal is adding decorative accents rather than building the page itself. The vintage sticker assortment includes nature-themed imagery such as butterflies, ferns, mushrooms, flowers, plants, and newspaper-style elements, so it suits junk journals, scrapbook pages, postcards, letters, and gift decoration. The material is listed as vinyl, and the item form is sheet, which points to an adhesive accent role. The limitation is that it is not a paper pack or cardstock base; shoppers looking for background layers, folded cards, or larger craft sheets will likely need a separate paper supply.

Colored Cardstock 50 Colors Bulk 150 Sheets,12" x 12" Cardstock Paper, 180 GS

This cardstock pack is the best match for makers who need solid colored paper for the structure of a project. It includes 50 colors and 150 sheets, with uses described around Cricut-style crafting, scrapbooking, greeting cards, banners, tags, party decor, folding, punching, and cutting. The 180 GSM cardstock description makes it more substantial than decorative paper ephemera. Its main limitation is style: it is color cardstock, not a vintage printed paper kit and not a sticker set. If your scrapbook page needs botanical motifs, old-script textures, or postcard-style layers, this pack would need to be paired with decorative elements.

200 Sheets of Vintage Scrapbook Paper, Journaling 6 Theme

This emmoolife paper set is a strong middle-ground choice for scrapbookers who want coordinated vintage paper layers without moving into a huge mixed kit. The six-theme assortment includes visual directions such as painting brush, flower, nature, portrait, palette, pigment, magazine, reminiscence, handwritten script, newspaper advertisements, journey, music sheets, celestial, and map. That range makes it useful for collages, junk journals, decoupage, handmade cards, envelopes, planners, and photo albums. The tradeoff is that it is centered on paper pieces, so shoppers who specifically want adhesive stickers or blank structural cardstock may find it less direct for those tasks.

517 Pcs Vintage Scrapbook Paper,Scrapbook Supplies Stickers,Journaling Supplies

The NESCCI vintage kit is the most assortment-style option here, with scrapbook papers, multiple design themes, and pressed flower sticker elements named in the description. It is especially appealing for journalers who want variety across petal, floral pattern, notes, postcard, abstract pattern, letter, music, and trace styles. The various smaller sizes can be useful for layering, framing, trimming, or filling corners of journal pages. The limitation is that the overall look stays within a vintage theme and smaller decorative pieces; it is not the same kind of full solid-color cardstock supply as the 50-color pack, and it may not be the first choice for large blank bases.

Final recommendation

For most paper crafts scrapbooking shoppers, the best choice depends on whether you are decorating, layering, or constructing. Pick 300 Pcs Vintage Stickers, Junk Journal Supplies, Cute Stickers for Journaling if you want the lowest listed price in the group and a straightforward vintage sticker assortment for journals and gifts. Choose 517 Pcs Vintage Scrapbook Paper,Scrapbook Supplies Stickers,Journaling Supplies if you want a low-priced mixed vintage bundle that includes both paper pieces and pressed flower sticker elements.

If your pages need more coordinated paper backgrounds, 200 Sheets of Vintage Scrapbook Paper, Journaling 6 Theme is the cleaner paper-focused choice, especially for collage, decoupage, and junk journal layering. If you are making cards, tags, banners, die cuts, or colorful bases, Colored Cardstock 50 Colors Bulk 150 Sheets,12" x 12" Cardstock Paper, 180 GS is the most practical structural supply, even though it is the highest listed price in this comparison.

Products in this article